“(Chantae) Miller and (Alistair) Sewell exude trust; when Miller credibly travels Caroline’s long arc and finally lets Anthony in, what ensues is so intimately tender it steals one’s breath. And that’s before we’ve even reached Gunderson’s brilliant eleventh-hour reveal, a gob smacker that left the Sunday matinee audience audibly gasping. It’s among the best and most satisfying moments I’ve had in a theater all year…”
– Mike Fischer, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Read more

“…there’s joy in watching Caroline and Anthony wander through Whitman’s words on life and death, searching for common ground under their boot-soles. They are, like this impassioned, lively drama, more than the sum of their parts.”
– Lindsay Christians, The Capital Times
Read more

“The two of them are onstage the entire show, and the energy between them is palpable.They dive into the meaning of life and death….Being witness to this visceral relationship is why we go to see live theater. And why we should go to I and You.”
– Cat Capellaro, Isthmus
Read more

“Though the two actors are young, they are immensely professional. They bring a maturity to this project that is rare to find, even in experienced adult actors. Occasionally, Miller’s performance would plateau in moments of anger and angst, but Sewell’s varied emotionality balanced this out, making them the perfect pair. The show is spectacularly directed by Jennifer Uphoff Gray, whose precise vision of Gunderson’s world is the reason that the play is so affecting.”
– Allison Garfield, The Daily Cardinal
Read more